中国经济空间格局演化与区域产业变迁——基于1952-2010年省区经济份额变动的实证分析

doi:10.13249/j.cnki.sgs.2015.01.56

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

从区域经济份额变化出发,分析了1952-2010年中国经济空间格局的演化过程。通过有序样本聚类的方法,将省区经济份额变动划分了8个阶段,并采用偏离-份额法分析了不同阶段驱动省区经济份额上升的产业及其变迁,以及与区域产业结构和竞争优势变化的关系。研究发现,1949年以来中国区域经济布局总体上经历了沿海-内地均衡发展、沿海化非均衡发展以及东、中、西部相对均衡发展的过程,且整体上区域经济份额变动趋于减小。1979年以前,不同区域的经济份额在不同阶段变化差异较大,主要由第一和第二产业驱动。1979年以后,区域经济格局呈现明显的沿海化趋势,但驱动产业在不同阶段有所变化。2001年以来,中国区域经济格局经历了重大调整,经济份额上升的省区明显由东部向中、西部地区转移。东部省区在第二产业上仍具有明显的结构优势,但第二产业竞争优势已由东部向中、西部地区转移。东部的北京、上海、广东在第三产业上呈现更加显著的结构优势,显示出结构升级和服务化的发展态势。

关键词: 省区经济份额变动, 区域产业变迁, 偏离-份额法, 有序样本聚类

Abstract:

Through analyzing the changes in economic shares of provinces in China from 1952 to 2010, we studied the evolution of China's spatial economy and regional industrial shift since the founding of the People's Republic of China. Previous studies mostly focused on the development of China’s spatial economy in the post-reform era, while our study used a long time series data set and tried to give the whole picture of the evolution of China’s spatial economy in almost 60 years. We divided the evolution of China's spatial economic pattern into eight phases by using the sequential sample cluster analysis, and then we applied the shift-share analysis to decompose the changes in economic shares of Chinese provinces and analyzed the industry that drove the increase of economic shares of provinces and its shift in different phases, as well as the relationship between the industrial shift and the changes in regional industrial mix and competitive advantages. Our findings showed that since the founding of the People's Republic of China, China's regional economy has experienced the balanced development of the coastal and interior regions, the unbalanced development with priority in the coastal areas, and the relatively balanced development among the eastern, central and western regions in general, at the same time, the average changes in economic shares of provinces tend to decrease over the phases. Before the economic reforms and the opening-up of China, economic shares of different regions in different phases changed dramatically and in different ways, which was mainly driven by the primary and secondary industries. After the economic reforms and the opening-up of China, the regional economy had shifted to the coastal areas evidently with the great increase of economic shares of the eastern and coastal provinces, while the industries that drove the increase of economic shares of coastal regions changed in different phases. Since 2000, China's regional economy has changed a lot, with the shift of regions with the increase of economic shares from the coastal provinces to the central and western provinces. Although the coastal areas still have the relatively high share of secondary industry in their industrial mix, the competitive advantages of secondary industry have shifted from the eastern areas to the central and western areas, which are indicated by the relatively higher growth rate of the secondary industry in the central and western provinces since 2000. Beijing, Shanghai and Guangdong in the east have shown more advantages in the tertiary industry with more share of tertiary industry in their industrial mix, which shows the tendency of upgrading and servicisation of regional economy in these areas.

Key words: changes in economic shares of provinces, regional industrial shift, shift-share analysis, sequential sample cluster analysis

中图分类号:

K902

孙铁山, 刘霄泉, 李国平. 中国经济空间格局演化与区域产业变迁——基于1952-2010年省区经济份额变动的实证分析[J]. 地理科学, 2015, 35(1): 56-65.

Tie-shan SUN, Xiao-quan LIU, Guo-ping LI. Evolution of China’s Spatial Economy and Regional Industrial Shift:Empirical Analysis of Changes in Economic Shares of Chinese Provinces from 1952 to 2010[J]. SCIENTIA GEOGRAPHICA SINICA, 2015, 35(1): 56-65.

图/表 5

表1

分阶段中国各地区和各省区经济份额变动情况"

地区	经济份额变动（%）
地区	1952-1958年	1958-1960年	1960-1966年	1966-1980年	1980-1986年	1986-1992年	1992-2001年	2001-2010年
东部	-2.092	1.585	-0.594	2.736	1.074	3.687	5.466	-0.859
北京	1.409	1.022	-1.065	0.530	-0.218	-0.214	0.688	-0.191
天津	0.449	0.223	-0.412	0.021	-0.342	-0.432	0.184	0.344
河北	-1.637	-0.215	0.041	0.225	-0.473	0.414	0.154	-0.420
上海	1.484	2.780	-2.791	-0.317	-2.028	-0.786	0.506	-0.878
江苏	-2.016	-0.264	0.947	0.755	0.433	0.531	0.480	0.766
浙江	-0.585	-0.359	0.423	0.636	1.111	0.106	1.057	-0.015
福建	-0.172	0.009	0.005	0.073	0.323	0.727	0.731	-0.384
山东	-1.448	-1.080	1.209	0.857	1.036	0.796	0.003	0.490
广东	0.423	-0.531	1.049	-0.044	1.232	2.544	1.664	-0.570
中部	-0.400	-1.403	1.308	-0.895	0.350	-2.325	-1.295	0.630
山西	0.475	0.162	-0.281	-0.478	-0.042	-0.309	-0.256	0.236
安徽	0.278	-0.145	-0.297	-0.345	0.756	-0.876	-0.098	-0.165
江西	-0.639	-0.054	0.507	-0.347	-0.142	-0.181	-0.204	0.158
河南	-1.142	-0.464	0.282	0.681	-0.011	-0.270	0.164	0.185
湖北	0.803	-0.686	0.898	-0.451	0.037	-0.379	-0.624	0.077
湖南	-0.175	-0.216	0.198	0.044	-0.249	-0.310	-0.276	0.139
西部	0.690	-2.832	2.416	-0.575	-0.511	-0.127	-2.344	1.373
内蒙古	0.210	0.171	-0.077	-0.723	0.324	-0.254	-0.047	1.096
广西	-0.175	-0.223	0.200	0.335	-0.089	0.369	-0.395	0.089
重庆	-0.247	-0.213	-0.172	-0.340	-0.167	-0.143	0.007	0.187
四川	0.845	-2.234	1.794	0.827	-0.479	-0.203	-0.586	-0.025
贵州	0.195	-0.106	-0.004	-0.101	0.073	-0.134	-0.268	0.009
云南	-0.109	-0.167	0.528	-0.245	-0.032	0.502	-0.417	-0.319
西藏	-0.082	0.031	0.046	-0.012	-0.022	-0.047	0.000	-0.012
陕西	0.326	0.056	-0.061	-0.245	-0.004	-0.106	-0.198	0.465
甘肃	-0.391	-0.628	0.294	0.244	-0.226	-0.232	-0.189	-0.095
青海	0.114	0.117	-0.113	0.024	-0.007	-0.061	-0.061	0.033
宁夏	-0.025	0.054	0.013	0.042	-0.006	-0.037	-0.010	0.076
新疆	0.029	0.311	-0.031	-0.381	0.124	0.217	-0.178	-0.131
东北	1.801	2.650	-3.130	-1.266	-0.912	-1.234	-1.827	-1.144
辽宁	1.498	1.981	-3.503	-0.295	-0.132	-0.586	-1.048	-0.418
吉林	-0.265	0.271	0.081	-0.531	0.108	-0.199	-0.199	0.029
黑龙江	0.568	0.398	0.292	-0.441	-0.888	-0.449	-0.580	-0.756
平均变动	0.101	0.253	0.098	0.025	0.062	0.069	0.042	0.032

表1

图1

图2

图3

图4

参考文献 17

[1]	魏后凯. 改革开放30 年中国区域经济的变迁——从不平衡发展到相对均衡发展[J]. 经济学动态, 2008,(5): 9-16.
[2]	刘乃全, 刘学华, 赵丽岗. 中国区域经济发展与空间结构的演变——基于改革开放 30 年时序变动的特征分析[J]. 财经研究, 2008, 34(11): 76-87.
[3]	孙久文, 年猛. 中国国土开发空间格局的演变研究[J]. 南京社会科学, 2011,(11): 8-14.
[4]	范剑勇, 朱国林. 中国地区差距演变及其结构分解[J]. 管理世界, 2002, 7: 37-44.
[5]	范剑勇. 产业结构失衡, 空间集聚与中国地区差距变化[J]. 上海经济研究, 2008, 2: 3-13.
[6]	关兴良, 方创琳, 罗奎. 基于空间场能的中国区域经济发展差异评价[J]. 地理科学, 2012, 32(9): 1055-1065.
[7]	欧向军, 沈正平, 王荣成. 中国区域经济增长与差异格局演变探析[J]. 地理科学, 2006, 26(6): 641-648.
[8]	鲁凤, 徐建华. 基于二阶段嵌套锡尔系数分解方法的中国区域经济差异研究[J]. 地理科学, 2005, 25(4): 401-407.
[9]	国家统计局国民经济综合统计司. 新中国六十年统计资料汇编[M]. 北京:中国统计出版社, 2010.
[10]	国家统计局. 中国统计年鉴2010[M]. 北京:中国统计出版社, 2010.
[11]	国家统计局. 中国统计年鉴2011[M]. 北京:中国统计出版社, 2011.
[12]	Fisher W D.On grouping for maximum homogeneity[J]. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 1958, 53: 789-798.
[13]	方开泰. 有序样品的一些聚类方法[J]. 应用数学学报, 1982, 5(1): 94-101.
[14]	严广松, 路允芳. 多维有序样本的聚类方法研究[J]. 统计与决策, 2008, (4): 29-30.
[15]	刘慧玲. 我国产业区域布局的发展历程与展望[J]. 工业技术经济, 2010, 29(11): 129-134.
[16]	袁晓玲, 张宝山, 杨万平. 动态偏离-份额分析法在区域经济中的应用[J]. 经济经纬, 2008, (1): 55-58.
[17]	Esteban-Marquillas J M. A reinterpretation of shift-share analysis[J]. Regional and Urban Economics, 1972, 2(3): 249-255.