基于城市形态发生学的商丘归德府古城空间特征分析

doi:10.13249/j.cnki.sgs.2016.07.006

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

采用城市形态发生学研究方法,在实地调研的基础上,利用历史文献、考古调查,结合古地图、航片、遥感影像等资料,对河南商丘归德府古城的城市形态进行了复原与分析。研究结果显示,归德府古城呈圆形的外边缘带,与呈方形的内边缘带,分别修筑于不同时期,具有不同的功能,“外圆内方”的空间形态实际上是城市变化的结果,反映了文化与自然环境两方面的作用。归德府城市形态各组成部分的变化并不一致,其中外郭城的变化最大,内城的变化相对较小,内城的街道、街区格局基本与清代的格局一致。内城的城墙-城门-护城河、棋盘格式街道格局、标志性建筑物（如文庙、府学等）,以及少量的呈点片状分布的古建筑和民居,构成了归德府城市形态主体,在中原地区具有典型性和唯一性,值得特别关注和保护。

关键词: 归德府古城, 城市形态发生学, 边缘带, 空间结构, 文化景观, 规划保护

Abstract:

Based on the investigation on the spot, using historical records, archaeological investigation, ancient maps, aerial photographs and remote sensing images, this article has reconstructed and analyzed the urban morphology of ancient prefecture city, Guidefu (Shangqiu) in Henan, from the angle of urban historical geography. The research shows that the Guide City has a circular outer edge and a square inner edge, built in different periods and had different functions, which means that the special form of Guide City “round outside but square inside” in fact is the result of comprehensive effect of the natural environment and social environment, and the reflection of time changes, while it is not a simple product of “Feng-shui” thought. The changes of parts of the urban morphology of Guide City do not consistent with each other, the outer part of the city changed a lot while the inner city changed less, and the streets and blocks in the city are nearly the same as it was in Qing Dynasty. The urban morphology and scale of Guide City represent the general characteristics of prefecture cities in Central China of Ming and Qing Dynasties, reflecting the characteristics of local culture and geographical environment of Central China, typical and unique. The walls-gates-moat, the chessboard street pattern, landmark building, such as Confucius' temple, and ancient residence distributed in dots and patches, constitute the main morphology of the ancient Guide City, and deserve special concern and protection. In the process of using Guide City to develop local cultural industry, urban planners should have a profound understanding of urban morphological characteristics, cultural landscape and the changing process of ancient city, in order to realize the combination of protection, development, and utilization in urban planning.

Key words: the Guidefu City, urban morphogenesis, the fringe belts, spatial structure, cultural landscape, urban planning

中图分类号:

K916

邓辉, 法念真. 基于城市形态发生学的商丘归德府古城空间特征分析[J]. 地理科学, 2016, 36(7): 1008-1016.

Hui Deng, Nianzhen Fa. Morphogenetic Analysis on Spatial Structure of the Guidefu City[J]. SCIENTIA GEOGRAPHICA SINICA, 2016, 36(7): 1008-1016.

图/表 5

参考文献 19

[1]	Pacione M.Historical Geography[M]// Whitehand J W R. Urban Morphology. New Hampshire: Croom Helm Ltd, 1987: 250-276.
[2]	Conzen M R G. Alnwick, Northumberland: A Study in Town-Plan Analysis[M]. London: Transactions and Papers (Institute of British Geographers), 1960, 27: 3-10.
[3]	Conzen M R G. Thinking about Urban Form, Papers on Urban Morphology, 1932-1998[C]. Oxford: Peter Lang AG, 2004: 60-77.
[4]	Vance J E Jr. The Continuing City: Urban Morphology in Western Civilization [M]. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990: 4-39.
[5]	段进, 邱国潮. 国外城市形态学研究的兴起与发展[J]. 城市规划学刊, 2008, (5): 34-42.
	[Duan Jin, Qiu Guochao.The emergence and development of overseas urban morphology study. Urban Planning Forum, 2008, (5): 34-42.]
[6]	J W R怀特汉德.宋峰,邓洁,译.城市形态区域化与城镇历史景观[J].中国园林,2010,(9): 53-58. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1000-6664.2010.09.014
	[ Whitehand J W R. Translated by Song F, Deng J. Urban Morphological Regionalization and Historical Urban Landscapes. Chinese Landscape Architecture, 2010, (9):53-58.] doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1000-6664.2010.09.014
[7]	张长寿,张光直.河南商丘地区殷商文明调查发掘初步报告[J].考古,1997,(4): 24-31.
	[Zhang C, Zhang G.The Preliminary Report on the Excavation of the Shang Civilization Survey in Shangqiu, Henan. Archaeology, 1997,(4):24-31.]
[8]	高天麟,慕容捷,荆志淳,等.河南商丘县东周城址勘查简报[J]. 考古,1998 (12): 18-27.
	[Gao T, Murong J, Jing Z et al. The Brief Report of the East Zhou Town Site Reconnaissance in Shanqiu, Henan. Archaeology, 1998(12): 18-27.]
[9]	穆章阿,李佐賢,等.(淸)嘉庆重修大清一统志[M].卷193,归德府,城池(四部丛刊本).
	[Mu Zhang’a, Li Zuoxian.Imperial Geography of the Qing Empire. Vol. 193, Guidefu, City (Chinese literature according to the four-category system).]
[10]	商丘县志编纂委员会.(清)商丘县志[M]. 郑州: 中州古籍出版社, 1989:50, 51, 57-58.
	[“Local Gazetteer of the County of Shangqiu” Editorial Board. (Qing) Local Gazetteer of Shangqiu County. Zhengzhou: Zhongzhou Ancient Books Press, 1989: 50,51,57-58.]
[11]	中国科学院《中国自然地理》编委会. 中国自然地理——历史自然地理[M]. 北京:科学出版社, 1982: 52-63.
	[Chinese Academy of Sciences “Natural Geography of China” Editorial Board. Natural Geography of China: Historical Geography. Beijing: Chinese Science Publishing & Media Ltd, 1982: 52-63.]
[12]	商丘地区文化局、商丘地区文物管理委员会.(清)重刻归德府志[M]. 商丘: 商丘地区文化局、商丘地区文物管理委员会,1980: 3-4.
	[Cultural Affairs Bureau, Antiquarian Committee in Shangqiu. (Qing) Re-engrave of Local Gazetteer of the Prefecture of Guidefu. Shangqiu: Cultural Affairs Bureau, Antiquarian Committee in Shangqiu, 1980, 1: 3-4.]
[13]	穆章阿,李佐賢,等.(淸)嘉庆重修大清一统志 [M].卷191,陈州府,城池(四部丛刊本).
	[Mu Zhang’a, Li Zuoxian.Imperial Geography of the Qing Empire. Vol. 191, Chenzhoufu, City (Chinese literature according to the four-category system).]
[14]	穆章阿,李佐賢,等.(淸)嘉庆重修大清一统志[M].卷181,曹州府,城池(四部丛刊本).
	[Mu Zhang’a, Li Zuoxian.Imperial Geography of the Qing Empire. Vol. 181, Caozhoufu, City (Chinese literature according to the four-category system).]
[15]	商丘县志编纂委员会.商丘县志(1938年商丘城图)[M]. 北京: 生活•读书•新知三联出版社,1991:64
	.[ “Local Gazetteer of the County of Shangqiu” Editorial Board. Local Gazetteer of the County of Shangqiu (City Map of Shangqiu in 1938). Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing Company, 1991:64].
[16]	商丘县志编纂委员会.商丘县志(1985年商丘城图)[M]. 北京: 生活•读书•新知三联出版社,1991:657.
	[ “Local Gazetteer of the County of Shangqiu” Editorial Board. Local Gazetteer of the County of Shangqiu (City Map of Shangqiu in 1985). Beijing: SDX Joint Publishing Company, 1991:65]
[17]	Wallacker B E.Chinese walled cities: a collection of maps from Shina Jokaku no Gaiy [M]. Hong Kong: Chinese University Press, 1979: 34-35.
[18]	邓辉. 卡尔·苏尔的文化生态学理论与实践[J]. 地理研究, 2003, 22(5): 625-634.
	[Deng Hui.On sauer's theory and practice in cultural ecology. Geographical Research, 2003, 22(5): 625-634.]
[19]	翟华伟.天下归德,盛世商丘[N/OL].京九晚报,商丘古城重建五百周年纪念特刊.2011-11-29(48).
	[Zhai H. Shangqiu, Prosperous from ancient Guidefu period till now. Jingjiu Evening, Commemorative Issue of the 500 Years’ Anniversary of the Ancient Shangqiu Reconstruction.2011-11-29(48). ]