多样vs.分裂：论中国人文地理学发展的多元性及其挑战

doi:10.13249/j.cnki.sgs.2019.01.003

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

从哲学、理论、方法和实践4个方面梳理了中国人文地理学内部的多元性,并区分了这些多元性的性质,即哪些是缺乏交流和整合的“散见”、哪些是需要统一和弥合的“歧见”、哪些是认识局限导致的“偏见”。据此建议加强中国人文地理学研究的问题意识和原创性理论研究;减少对“主义”的过度推崇和对方法的盲目崇拜;加强定性方法和定量方法的交流及论证过程的严谨性;在政策取向上取得“求真”和“务实”的平衡;提高学科发展的自信和对不同研究视角的包容。此外,应该在研究选题、杂志建设和奖项设置等操作层面推动人文地理学的理论整合。

关键词: 多元性, 人文地理学, 地理学思想, 地理哲学, 人文地理学理论, 人文地理学方法

Abstract:

In last 40 years, Chinese Human Geography has made great achievements in terms of the integrity of disciplinary system, number of research in geographical journals, and social and political impacts of Human Geography graduates. However, there are also many challenges in the development of Chinese Human Geography. The most salient one is the pluralism of Chinese human geographical studies, which leads to the blurred definition, undermined identification and reduced impact of human geography. The article tries to scrutinize and distinguish the types of pluralism in Chinese Human Geography in the aspects of philosophy, theory, method and practice. 3 types of pluralism are summarized and their implications for the future studies are discussed, i.e. the dispersed disagreements (sanjian) which require more communication and integration, the divided ideas (qijian) which need to be unified and bridged, and narrow prejudice (pianjian) which should be dispelled and opened up. This article suggests that Chinese Human Geography should enhance consciousness of raising good research questions and develop more original theories, abandon the excessive worship of new doctrines and methods, promote the communication and combination of qualitative and quantitative methods, improve the rigor of arguments, balance “realistic” and “pragmatic” orientations in policy-making, and integrate diverse research perspectives. We also provide some detailed practical recommendations in future research directions and disciplinary development.

Key words: pluralism, Human Geography, geographical thoughts, geographical philosophy, human geographical theory, human geographical method

中图分类号:

K901

王丰龙,刘云刚. 多样vs.分裂：论中国人文地理学发展的多元性及其挑战[J]. 地理科学, 2019, 39(1): 22-30.

Fenglong Wang,Yungang Liu. Diversity vs. Division: The Pluralism and Its Challenges for Contemporary Chinese Human Geography[J]. SCIENTIA GEOGRAPHICA SINICA, 2019, 39(1): 22-30.

参考文献 41

[41]	[ Wang Fenglong, Zeng Gang . A review and prospect on studies of Yangtze river economic belt. World Regional Studies, 2017,26(2):62-71.]
[42]	唐晓峰 . “反向格义”与中国地理学史研究[J]. 南京大学学报(哲学·人文科学·社会科学版), 2009(2):81-91.
	[ Tang Xiaofeng . Reverse anlogical interpretation and studies of Chinese history of geography. Journal of Nanjing University, 2009(2):81-91.]
[43]	刘云刚, 王丰龙 . 西方主义与实证主义幻象:近三十年来中国人文地理学理论研究透视[J]. 人文地理, 2013,28(1):14-19.
	[ Liu Yungang, Wang Fenglong . Reexamining Chinese human geography: perspective of theoretical studies in recent thirty years. Human Geography, 2013,28(1):14-19.]
[44]	Wang F, Liu Y . How unique is ‘China Model’: A review of theoretical perspectives on China’s urbanization in Anglophone literature[J]. Chinese Geographical Science, 2015,25(1):98-112.
[45]	С Б 拉夫罗夫, 陈家振, 宋广生 . 现代地理学的发展趋势及其统一性问题[J]. 地理译报, 1984,3(4):1-5.
	[ С Б лаврович, Chen Jiazheng, Song Guangsheng . The development trend of modern geography and its uniformity. Progress in Geography, 1984,3(4):1-5.]
[1]	李旭旦 . 人地关系的回顾与瞻望——兼论人文地理学的创新[J]. 世界地理集刊, 1981(2):3-7.
	[ Li Xudan . The review and prospect of man-earth relationship: the innovation of human geography. World Geographic Magazine, 1981(2):3-7.]
[46]	梁进社 . 地理学的十四大原理[J]. 地理科学, 2009,29(3):307-315.
	[ Liang Jinshe . Fourteen principles in geography. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2009,29(3):307-315.]
[2]	陆大道, 郭来喜 . 地理学的研究核心——人地关系地域系统——论吴传钧院士的地理学思想与学术贡献[J]. 地理学报, 1998,53(2):3-11.
	[ Lu Dadao, Guo Laixi . Man-earth areal system——The core of geographical study: On the geographical thoughts and academic contributions of academician Wu Chuanjun. Acta Geographica Sinica, 1998,53(2):3-11.]
[47]	胡兆量 . 地理学的基本规律[J]. 人文地理, 1991,6(1):9-13.
	[ Hu Zhaoliang . The basic rules of geography. Human Geography, 1991,6(1):9-13.]
[3]	任美锷 . 最近十年来中国地理科学的进展[J]. 地理学报, 1990,45(2):132-138.
	[ Ren Meie . Development of geographical science in the last decade. Acta Geographica Sinica, 1990,45(2):132-138.]
[48]	陈彦光 . 对称性与人文地理系统的规律性[J]. 地理科学进展, 2009,28(2):312-320. doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2009.02.022
	[ Chen Yanguang . New way of looking at human geographical laws using the idea from symmetry. Progress in Geography, 2009,28(2):312-320.] doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2009.02.022
[4]	蔡运龙, 陆大道, 周一星 , 等. 地理科学的中国进展与国际趋势[J]. 地理学报, 2004,59(6):803-810.
	[ Cai Yunlong, Lu Dadao , Zhou Yixing et al. Chinese progress and international trends of geography. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2004,59(6):803-810.]
[49]	王丰龙, 刘云刚 . 空间生产再考:从哈维到福柯[J]. 地理科学, 2013,33(11):1293-1301.
	[ Wang Fenglong, Liu Yungang . Revisiting production of space: from Harvey to Foucault. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2013,33(11):1293-1301.]
[5]	李润田 . 中国地理学发展的世纪回顾与展望[J]. 地理科学, 2008,28(1):10-14.
	[ Li Runtian . Review and prospect of development of geography in China. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2008,28(1):10-14.]
[6]	朱竑, 陈晓亮 . 从台湾《地理学报》看两岸人文地理学的发展[J]. 地理学报, 2009,64(12):1534-1548.
	[ Zhu Hong, Chen Xiaoliang . The development of similarities and differences in human geography across the Taiwan straits on the study of Journal of Geographical Science in Taiwan. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2009,64(12):1534-1548.]
[50]	刘瑜 . 飞越流水线[M] // 刘瑜. 送你一颗子弹. 上海: 上海三联书店, 2010: 183-186.
	[ Liu Yu. Fly over the pipeline. // Send you a bullet. Shanghai: SDX Joint Publishing Company, 2010: 183-186.]
[7]	樊杰, 孙威 . 中国人文-经济地理学科进展及展望[J]. 地理科学进展, 2011,30(12):1459-1469. doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2011.12.001
	[ Fan Jie, Sun Wei . Recent progress and outlook of human-economic geography in China. Progress in Geography, 2011,30(12):1459-1469.] doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2011.12.001
[8]	方创琳, 周尚意, 柴彦威 , 等. 中国人文地理学研究进展与展望[J]. 地理科学进展, 2011,30(12):1470-1478. doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2011.12.002
	[ Fang Chuanglin, Zhou Shangyi , Chai Yanwei et al. Updated progress and perspectives of the discipline of human geography in China. Progress in Geography, 2011,30(12):1470-1478.] doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2011.12.002
[51]	Mankiw N G . The Macroeconomist as Scientist and Engineer[J]. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2006,20(4):29-46.
[52]	Marston S A, Jones J P, Woodward K . Human geography without scale[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2005,30(4):416-432.
[9]	曹诗图, 孙天胜 . 试论中国地理学的变革[J]. 地理研究, 2000,19(1):107-112.
	[ Cao Shitu, Sun Tiansheng . On the transformation of geography in China. Geographical Research, 2000,19(1):107-112.]
[53]	Abler R F . What Shall We Say? To Whom Shall We Speak?[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 1987,77(4):511-524.
[54]	邓正来 . 知识生产机器的反思与批判——迈向中国学术规范化讨论的第二阶段[J]. 西南政法大学学报, 2004,6(3):3-6.
[10]	汤茂林 . 我国人文地理学研究的若干基本意识问题[J]. 人文地理, 2010,25(4):1-6.
	[ Tang Maolin . The methodological issues of human geography researches in mainland China. Human Geography, 2010,25(4):1-6.]
[54]	[ Deng Zhenglai . Retrospecting and criticizing the apparatus which knowledge is made out of. Journal of SWUPL, 2004,6(3):3-6.]
[55]	费希尔C A, 陈秀容 . 区域地理学往何处去?[J]. 地理译报, 1982,1(4):10-14.
[11]	王丰龙, 刘云刚 . 空间和尺度视角下的人文地理学要义再考[M] //地理学核心问题与主线.乌鲁木齐:中国地理学会2011年学术年会, 2011.
	[ Wang Fenglong, Liu Yungang . Rethinking the key concepts in human geography from the perspective of space and scale. The key questions and principle lines in Geography. Urumqi:The Geographical Society of China 2011 Anual Conference, 2011: 4.]
[55]	[ Fisher C A, Chen Xiurong . Where geographical geography is going? Progress in Geography, 1982,1(4):10-14.]
[56]	胡适 . 胡适作品系列:问题与主义[M]. 北京: 北京大学出版社, 2013: 1-313.
[12]	Johnston R, Sidaway J D . Geography and geographers: Anglo-American human geography since 1945[M]. New York: Routledge, 2015: 1-520.
[13]	周素卿 . 台湾人文地理学的研究进程: 知识生产特性与学科进步性之探讨[J]. 都市与计划(中国台湾), 2002,29(2):265-289.
[56]	[ Hu Shi. Hu Shi series: Problem and doctrine. Beijing: Peking University Press, 2013: 1-313.]
[57]	刘云刚, 李志刚, 黎斌 . 西方人文地理学研究评述与借鉴——面向知行合一的中国人文地理学[J]. 地理学报, 2014,69(8):1224-1233.
[13]	[ Zhou Suqing . The research process of human geography in Taiwan: the study of the characteristics of knowledge production and the progress of the subject. City and Planning (Taiwan, China), 2002,29(2):265-289.]
[14]	刘云刚, 许学强 . 中国地理学的二元结构[J]. 地理科学, 2008,28(5):587-593.
	[ Liu Yungang, Xu Xueqiang . Duality of Chinese geography. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2008,28(5):587-593.]
[15]	叶超, 蔡运龙 . 区域地理与系统地理二元论的演变及其透析[J]. 地理研究, 2012,31(5):771-781.
[57]	[ Liu Yungang, Li Zhigang, Li Bin . A critical review of research methods of Western human geography: a combination of knowing and doing for Chinese human geography. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014,69(8):1224-1233.]
[58]	陈彦光, 刘继生 . 地理学的主要任务与研究方法——从整个科学体系的视角看地理科学的发展[J]. 地理科学, 2004,24(3):257-263.
[15]	[ Ye Chao, Cai Yunlong . Causes and effects of dualism between regional geography and systematic geography. Geographical Research, 2012,31(5):771-781.]
[16]	汤茂林 . 问题主导还是方法主导?——对我国人文地理学研究的方法论思考[J]. 人文地理, 2013,28(5):19-23.
[58]	[ Chen Yanguang, Liu Jisheng . Main tasks and methods of geography. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2004,24(3):257-263.]
[59]	Wallerstein I. Open the social sciences: Report of the Gulbenkian Commission on the restructuring of the social sciences[M]. Redwood: Stanford University Press, 1996: 1-128.
[16]	[ Tang Maolin . Problem-dominated versus method-dominated? The reflection on the methodology of human geography research in mainland China. Human Geography, 2013,28(5):19-23.]
[17]	刘卫东, 柴彦威, 周尚意 . 地理学评论(第一辑)[M]. 北京: 商务印书馆, 2009: 1-181.
	[ Liu Weidong, Chai Yanwei, Zhou Shangyi. Geographical review(The first series). Beijing: The Commercial Press, 2009: 1-181.]
[18]	保继刚 . 从理想主义、现实主义到理想主义理性回归——中国旅游地理学发展30年回顾[J]. 地理学报, 2009,64(10):1184-1192.
	[ Bao Jigang . From idealism to realism to rational idealism: Reflection on 30 years of development in tourism geography in China. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2009,64(10):1184-1192.]
[19]	刘云刚, 许学强 . 实用主义VS科学主义:中国城市地理学的研究取向[J]. 地理研究, 2010,29(11):2059-2069.
	[ Liu Yungang, Xu Xueqiang . Pragmatism vs. scientism: Which is the sponsor of urban geography in China ? Geographical Research, 2010,29(11):2059-2069.]
[20]	陆大道 . 地理科学的价值与地理学者的情怀[J]. 地理学报, 2015,70(10):1539-1551.
	[ Lu Dadao . The value of geographical science and the feelings of geographers. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2015,70(10):1539-1551.]
[21]	刘云刚 . 地理学的政治[J]. 地理研究, 2013,32(11):2170-2175.
	[ Liu Yungang . The politics of Chinese geography. Geographical Research, 2013,32(11):2170-2175.]
[22]	汤茂林 . 哲学、方法论与实践反思——《人文地理学方法》述评[J]. 地理学报, 2017,72(8):1531-1533.
	[ Tang Maolin . Philosophy, methodology and practical reflection: A review of “Approaches to Human Geography”. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2017,72(8):1531-1533.]
[23]	汤茂林 . 我国人文地理学研究方法多样化问题[J]. 地理研究, 2009,28(4):865-882.
	[ Tang Maolin . The diversification of research approaches in human geography in Chinese Mainland. Geographical Research, 2009,28(4):865-882.]
[24]	李旭旦, 陆诚 . 论十九世纪德国地理学的统一性观点[J]. 地理研究, 1983,2(3):1-7.
	[ Li Xudan, Lu Cheng . On the integrity conception of the 19th century’s geography in Germany. Geographical Research, 1983,2(3):1-7.]
[25]	唐晓峰, 李平 . 人文地理学理论的多元性[J]. 人文地理, 2001,16(2):42-44.
	[ Tang Xiaofeng, Li Ping . The theoretical variety in the studies of human geography. Human Geography, 2001,16(2):42-44.]
[26]	刘凯, 秦耀辰, 毋河海 , 等. 本体论、后现代主义与地理学的发展[J]. 人文地理, 2007,22(3):18-21.
	[ Liu Kai, Qin Yaocheng , Wu Hehai et al. Ontology, post-modernism and the progress of geography. Human Geography, 2007,22(3):18-21.]
[27]	钱俊希, 朱竑 . 新文化地理学的理论统一性与话题多样性[J]. 地理研究, 2015,34(3):422-436.
	[ Qian Junxi, Zhu Hong . Theoretical unity and thematic diversity in new cultural geography. Geographical Research, 2015,34(3):422-436.]
[28]	Aitken S, Valentine G . Approaches to Human Geography[M]. London: Sage, 2006.
[29]	Peet R . Modern geographical thought[M]. London: Blackwell, 1998.
[30]	Johnston R J . Philosophy and human geography: An introduction to contemporary approaches[M]. London: Edward Arnold, 1986: 1-178.
[31]	苗长虹 . 变革中的西方经济地理学:制度、文化、关系与尺度转向[J]. 人文地理, 2004,19(4):68-76.
	[ Miao Changhong . Western economic geography in transformation: Institutional, cultural, relational and scalar turns. Human Geography, 2004,19(4):68-76.]
[32]	顾朝林 . 人文地理学流派[M]. 北京: 高等教育出版社, 2008: 1-170.
	[ Gu Chaolin. School of Human Geography. Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2008: 1-170.]
[33]	柴彦威 . 城市地理学思想与方法[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2016: 1-372.
	[ Chai Yanwei. Urban Geography Thought and Method. Beijing: Science Press, 2016: 1-372.]
[34]	白光润 . 地理学的哲学贫困[J]. 地理学报, 1995,50(3):279-287.
	[ Bai Guangrun . The philosophy predicament in the development of geography. Acta Geographica Sinica, 1995,50(3):279-287.]
[35]	沈玉昌, 左大康, 谭见安 , 等. 我国地理学的方向与任务若干问题的商讨[J]. 地理学报, 1980,35(2):108-115.
	[ Shen Yuchang, Zuo Dakang , Tan Jian'an et al. The orientation and task of geography in China: A discussion of some problems. Acta Geographica Sinica, 1980,35(2):108-115.]
[36]	唐晓峰 . 从混沌到秩序:中国上古地理思想史述论[M]. 北京: 中华书局, 2010.
	[ Tang Xiaofeng . From chaos to order: The review of ancient geographical thought in China. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, 2010.]
[37]	张京祥 . 西方城市规划思想史纲[M]. 南京: 东南大学出版社, 2005.
	[ Zhang Jingxiang. History of urban planning in western cities. Nanjing: Southeast University Press, 2005.]
[38]	陈彦光 . 地理学的贫困与出路(Ⅰ)——地理学危机的哲学思考[J]. 信阳师范学院学报(自然科学版), 1998,11(1):77-80.
	[ Chen Yanguang . Poverty and way-out of geography(Ⅰ): philosophy reflections on the geographical crisis. Journal of Xinyang Teachers College(Natural Science Edition), 1998,11(1):77-80.]
[39]	刘笑敢 . 反向格义与中国哲学方法论反思[J]. 哲学研究, 2006(4):34-39.
	[ Liu Xiaogan . Reflection on Fanxiang Geyi (Reverse Analogical Interpretation) and the Methodology of Chinese Philosophy. Philosophical Researches, 2006(4):34-39.]
[40]	周一星 . 城市研究的第一科学问题是基本概念的正确性[J]. 城市规划学刊, 2006(1):1-5.
	[ Zhou Yixing . The primary scientific issue of urban research in China is the correctness of basic urban concepts. Urban Planning Forum, 2006(1):1-5.]
[60]	de Blij H . Why geography matters: Three challenges facing America[M]. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007.
[41]	王丰龙, 曾刚 . 长江经济带研究综述与展望[J]. 世界地理研究, 2017,26(2):62-71.