地理科学 ›› 2019, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (1): 22-30.doi: 10.13249/j.cnki.sgs.2019.01.003
收稿日期:
2017-12-30
修回日期:
2018-07-21
出版日期:
2019-01-10
发布日期:
2019-01-10
作者简介:
王丰龙(1988-),男,内蒙古赤峰人,副教授,主要研究方向为政治地理学、幸福地理学和地理学思想。E-mail: 基金资助:
Fenglong Wang1,2,Yungang Liu3()
Received:
2017-12-30
Revised:
2018-07-21
Online:
2019-01-10
Published:
2019-01-10
Supported by:
摘要:
从哲学、理论、方法和实践4个方面梳理了中国人文地理学内部的多元性,并区分了这些多元性的性质,即哪些是缺乏交流和整合的“散见”、哪些是需要统一和弥合的“歧见”、哪些是认识局限导致的“偏见”。据此建议加强中国人文地理学研究的问题意识和原创性理论研究;减少对“主义”的过度推崇和对方法的盲目崇拜;加强定性方法和定量方法的交流及论证过程的严谨性;在政策取向上取得“求真”和“务实”的平衡;提高学科发展的自信和对不同研究视角的包容。此外,应该在研究选题、杂志建设和奖项设置等操作层面推动人文地理学的理论整合。
中图分类号:
王丰龙,刘云刚. 多样vs.分裂:论中国人文地理学发展的多元性及其挑战[J]. 地理科学, 2019, 39(1): 22-30.
Fenglong Wang,Yungang Liu. Diversity vs. Division: The Pluralism and Its Challenges for Contemporary Chinese Human Geography[J]. SCIENTIA GEOGRAPHICA SINICA, 2019, 39(1): 22-30.
[41] | [ Wang Fenglong, Zeng Gang . A review and prospect on studies of Yangtze river economic belt. World Regional Studies, 2017,26(2):62-71.] |
[42] | 唐晓峰 . “反向格义”与中国地理学史研究[J]. 南京大学学报(哲学·人文科学·社会科学版), 2009(2):81-91. |
[ Tang Xiaofeng . Reverse anlogical interpretation and studies of Chinese history of geography. Journal of Nanjing University, 2009(2):81-91.] | |
[43] | 刘云刚, 王丰龙 . 西方主义与实证主义幻象:近三十年来中国人文地理学理论研究透视[J]. 人文地理, 2013,28(1):14-19. |
[ Liu Yungang, Wang Fenglong . Reexamining Chinese human geography: perspective of theoretical studies in recent thirty years. Human Geography, 2013,28(1):14-19.] | |
[44] | Wang F, Liu Y . How unique is ‘China Model’: A review of theoretical perspectives on China’s urbanization in Anglophone literature[J]. Chinese Geographical Science, 2015,25(1):98-112. |
[45] | С Б 拉夫罗夫, 陈家振, 宋广生 . 现代地理学的发展趋势及其统一性问题[J]. 地理译报, 1984,3(4):1-5. |
[ С Б лаврович, Chen Jiazheng, Song Guangsheng . The development trend of modern geography and its uniformity. Progress in Geography, 1984,3(4):1-5.] | |
[1] | 李旭旦 . 人地关系的回顾与瞻望——兼论人文地理学的创新[J]. 世界地理集刊, 1981(2):3-7. |
[ Li Xudan . The review and prospect of man-earth relationship: the innovation of human geography. World Geographic Magazine, 1981(2):3-7.] | |
[46] | 梁进社 . 地理学的十四大原理[J]. 地理科学, 2009,29(3):307-315. |
[ Liang Jinshe . Fourteen principles in geography. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2009,29(3):307-315.] | |
[2] | 陆大道, 郭来喜 . 地理学的研究核心——人地关系地域系统——论吴传钧院士的地理学思想与学术贡献[J]. 地理学报, 1998,53(2):3-11. |
[ Lu Dadao, Guo Laixi . Man-earth areal system——The core of geographical study: On the geographical thoughts and academic contributions of academician Wu Chuanjun. Acta Geographica Sinica, 1998,53(2):3-11.] | |
[47] | 胡兆量 . 地理学的基本规律[J]. 人文地理, 1991,6(1):9-13. |
[ Hu Zhaoliang . The basic rules of geography. Human Geography, 1991,6(1):9-13.] | |
[3] | 任美锷 . 最近十年来中国地理科学的进展[J]. 地理学报, 1990,45(2):132-138. |
[ Ren Meie . Development of geographical science in the last decade. Acta Geographica Sinica, 1990,45(2):132-138.] | |
[48] |
陈彦光 . 对称性与人文地理系统的规律性[J]. 地理科学进展, 2009,28(2):312-320.
doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2009.02.022 |
[ Chen Yanguang . New way of looking at human geographical laws using the idea from symmetry. Progress in Geography, 2009,28(2):312-320.]
doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2009.02.022 |
|
[4] | 蔡运龙, 陆大道, 周一星 , 等. 地理科学的中国进展与国际趋势[J]. 地理学报, 2004,59(6):803-810. |
[ Cai Yunlong, Lu Dadao , Zhou Yixing et al. Chinese progress and international trends of geography. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2004,59(6):803-810.] | |
[49] | 王丰龙, 刘云刚 . 空间生产再考:从哈维到福柯[J]. 地理科学, 2013,33(11):1293-1301. |
[ Wang Fenglong, Liu Yungang . Revisiting production of space: from Harvey to Foucault. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2013,33(11):1293-1301.] | |
[5] | 李润田 . 中国地理学发展的世纪回顾与展望[J]. 地理科学, 2008,28(1):10-14. |
[ Li Runtian . Review and prospect of development of geography in China. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2008,28(1):10-14.] | |
[6] | 朱竑, 陈晓亮 . 从台湾《地理学报》看两岸人文地理学的发展[J]. 地理学报, 2009,64(12):1534-1548. |
[ Zhu Hong, Chen Xiaoliang . The development of similarities and differences in human geography across the Taiwan straits on the study of Journal of Geographical Science in Taiwan. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2009,64(12):1534-1548.] | |
[50] | 刘瑜 . 飞越流水线[M] // 刘瑜. 送你一颗子弹. 上海: 上海三联书店, 2010: 183-186. |
[ Liu Yu. Fly over the pipeline. // Send you a bullet. Shanghai: SDX Joint Publishing Company, 2010: 183-186.] | |
[7] |
樊杰, 孙威 . 中国人文-经济地理学科进展及展望[J]. 地理科学进展, 2011,30(12):1459-1469.
doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2011.12.001 |
[ Fan Jie, Sun Wei . Recent progress and outlook of human-economic geography in China. Progress in Geography, 2011,30(12):1459-1469.]
doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2011.12.001 |
|
[8] |
方创琳, 周尚意, 柴彦威 , 等. 中国人文地理学研究进展与展望[J]. 地理科学进展, 2011,30(12):1470-1478.
doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2011.12.002 |
[ Fang Chuanglin, Zhou Shangyi , Chai Yanwei et al. Updated progress and perspectives of the discipline of human geography in China. Progress in Geography, 2011,30(12):1470-1478.]
doi: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2011.12.002 |
|
[51] | Mankiw N G . The Macroeconomist as Scientist and Engineer[J]. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2006,20(4):29-46. |
[52] | Marston S A, Jones J P, Woodward K . Human geography without scale[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2005,30(4):416-432. |
[9] | 曹诗图, 孙天胜 . 试论中国地理学的变革[J]. 地理研究, 2000,19(1):107-112. |
[ Cao Shitu, Sun Tiansheng . On the transformation of geography in China. Geographical Research, 2000,19(1):107-112.] | |
[53] | Abler R F . What Shall We Say? To Whom Shall We Speak?[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 1987,77(4):511-524. |
[54] | 邓正来 . 知识生产机器的反思与批判——迈向中国学术规范化讨论的第二阶段[J]. 西南政法大学学报, 2004,6(3):3-6. |
[10] | 汤茂林 . 我国人文地理学研究的若干基本意识问题[J]. 人文地理, 2010,25(4):1-6. |
[ Tang Maolin . The methodological issues of human geography researches in mainland China. Human Geography, 2010,25(4):1-6.] | |
[54] | [ Deng Zhenglai . Retrospecting and criticizing the apparatus which knowledge is made out of. Journal of SWUPL, 2004,6(3):3-6.] |
[55] | 费希尔C A, 陈秀容 . 区域地理学往何处去?[J]. 地理译报, 1982,1(4):10-14. |
[11] | 王丰龙, 刘云刚 . 空间和尺度视角下的人文地理学要义再考[M] //地理学核心问题与主线.乌鲁木齐:中国地理学会2011年学术年会, 2011. |
[ Wang Fenglong, Liu Yungang . Rethinking the key concepts in human geography from the perspective of space and scale. The key questions and principle lines in Geography. Urumqi:The Geographical Society of China 2011 Anual Conference, 2011: 4.] | |
[55] | [ Fisher C A, Chen Xiurong . Where geographical geography is going? Progress in Geography, 1982,1(4):10-14.] |
[56] | 胡适 . 胡适作品系列:问题与主义[M]. 北京: 北京大学出版社, 2013: 1-313. |
[12] | Johnston R, Sidaway J D . Geography and geographers: Anglo-American human geography since 1945[M]. New York: Routledge, 2015: 1-520. |
[13] | 周素卿 . 台湾人文地理学的研究进程: 知识生产特性与学科进步性之探讨[J]. 都市与计划(中国台湾), 2002,29(2):265-289. |
[56] | [ Hu Shi. Hu Shi series: Problem and doctrine. Beijing: Peking University Press, 2013: 1-313.] |
[57] | 刘云刚, 李志刚, 黎斌 . 西方人文地理学研究评述与借鉴——面向知行合一的中国人文地理学[J]. 地理学报, 2014,69(8):1224-1233. |
[13] | [ Zhou Suqing . The research process of human geography in Taiwan: the study of the characteristics of knowledge production and the progress of the subject. City and Planning (Taiwan, China), 2002,29(2):265-289.] |
[14] | 刘云刚, 许学强 . 中国地理学的二元结构[J]. 地理科学, 2008,28(5):587-593. |
[ Liu Yungang, Xu Xueqiang . Duality of Chinese geography. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2008,28(5):587-593.] | |
[15] | 叶超, 蔡运龙 . 区域地理与系统地理二元论的演变及其透析[J]. 地理研究, 2012,31(5):771-781. |
[57] | [ Liu Yungang, Li Zhigang, Li Bin . A critical review of research methods of Western human geography: a combination of knowing and doing for Chinese human geography. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014,69(8):1224-1233.] |
[58] | 陈彦光, 刘继生 . 地理学的主要任务与研究方法——从整个科学体系的视角看地理科学的发展[J]. 地理科学, 2004,24(3):257-263. |
[15] | [ Ye Chao, Cai Yunlong . Causes and effects of dualism between regional geography and systematic geography. Geographical Research, 2012,31(5):771-781.] |
[16] | 汤茂林 . 问题主导还是方法主导?——对我国人文地理学研究的方法论思考[J]. 人文地理, 2013,28(5):19-23. |
[58] | [ Chen Yanguang, Liu Jisheng . Main tasks and methods of geography. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2004,24(3):257-263.] |
[59] | Wallerstein I. Open the social sciences: Report of the Gulbenkian Commission on the restructuring of the social sciences[M]. Redwood: Stanford University Press, 1996: 1-128. |
[16] | [ Tang Maolin . Problem-dominated versus method-dominated? The reflection on the methodology of human geography research in mainland China. Human Geography, 2013,28(5):19-23.] |
[17] | 刘卫东, 柴彦威, 周尚意 . 地理学评论(第一辑)[M]. 北京: 商务印书馆, 2009: 1-181. |
[ Liu Weidong, Chai Yanwei, Zhou Shangyi. Geographical review(The first series). Beijing: The Commercial Press, 2009: 1-181.] | |
[18] | 保继刚 . 从理想主义、现实主义到理想主义理性回归——中国旅游地理学发展30年回顾[J]. 地理学报, 2009,64(10):1184-1192. |
[ Bao Jigang . From idealism to realism to rational idealism: Reflection on 30 years of development in tourism geography in China. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2009,64(10):1184-1192.] | |
[19] | 刘云刚, 许学强 . 实用主义VS科学主义:中国城市地理学的研究取向[J]. 地理研究, 2010,29(11):2059-2069. |
[ Liu Yungang, Xu Xueqiang . Pragmatism vs. scientism: Which is the sponsor of urban geography in China ? Geographical Research, 2010,29(11):2059-2069.] | |
[20] | 陆大道 . 地理科学的价值与地理学者的情怀[J]. 地理学报, 2015,70(10):1539-1551. |
[ Lu Dadao . The value of geographical science and the feelings of geographers. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2015,70(10):1539-1551.] | |
[21] | 刘云刚 . 地理学的政治[J]. 地理研究, 2013,32(11):2170-2175. |
[ Liu Yungang . The politics of Chinese geography. Geographical Research, 2013,32(11):2170-2175.] | |
[22] | 汤茂林 . 哲学、方法论与实践反思——《人文地理学方法》述评[J]. 地理学报, 2017,72(8):1531-1533. |
[ Tang Maolin . Philosophy, methodology and practical reflection: A review of “Approaches to Human Geography”. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2017,72(8):1531-1533.] | |
[23] | 汤茂林 . 我国人文地理学研究方法多样化问题[J]. 地理研究, 2009,28(4):865-882. |
[ Tang Maolin . The diversification of research approaches in human geography in Chinese Mainland. Geographical Research, 2009,28(4):865-882.] | |
[24] | 李旭旦, 陆诚 . 论十九世纪德国地理学的统一性观点[J]. 地理研究, 1983,2(3):1-7. |
[ Li Xudan, Lu Cheng . On the integrity conception of the 19th century’s geography in Germany. Geographical Research, 1983,2(3):1-7.] | |
[25] | 唐晓峰, 李平 . 人文地理学理论的多元性[J]. 人文地理, 2001,16(2):42-44. |
[ Tang Xiaofeng, Li Ping . The theoretical variety in the studies of human geography. Human Geography, 2001,16(2):42-44.] | |
[26] | 刘凯, 秦耀辰, 毋河海 , 等. 本体论、后现代主义与地理学的发展[J]. 人文地理, 2007,22(3):18-21. |
[ Liu Kai, Qin Yaocheng , Wu Hehai et al. Ontology, post-modernism and the progress of geography. Human Geography, 2007,22(3):18-21.] | |
[27] | 钱俊希, 朱竑 . 新文化地理学的理论统一性与话题多样性[J]. 地理研究, 2015,34(3):422-436. |
[ Qian Junxi, Zhu Hong . Theoretical unity and thematic diversity in new cultural geography. Geographical Research, 2015,34(3):422-436.] | |
[28] | Aitken S, Valentine G . Approaches to Human Geography[M]. London: Sage, 2006. |
[29] | Peet R . Modern geographical thought[M]. London: Blackwell, 1998. |
[30] | Johnston R J . Philosophy and human geography: An introduction to contemporary approaches[M]. London: Edward Arnold, 1986: 1-178. |
[31] | 苗长虹 . 变革中的西方经济地理学:制度、文化、关系与尺度转向[J]. 人文地理, 2004,19(4):68-76. |
[ Miao Changhong . Western economic geography in transformation: Institutional, cultural, relational and scalar turns. Human Geography, 2004,19(4):68-76.] | |
[32] | 顾朝林 . 人文地理学流派[M]. 北京: 高等教育出版社, 2008: 1-170. |
[ Gu Chaolin. School of Human Geography. Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2008: 1-170.] | |
[33] | 柴彦威 . 城市地理学思想与方法[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2016: 1-372. |
[ Chai Yanwei. Urban Geography Thought and Method. Beijing: Science Press, 2016: 1-372.] | |
[34] | 白光润 . 地理学的哲学贫困[J]. 地理学报, 1995,50(3):279-287. |
[ Bai Guangrun . The philosophy predicament in the development of geography. Acta Geographica Sinica, 1995,50(3):279-287.] | |
[35] | 沈玉昌, 左大康, 谭见安 , 等. 我国地理学的方向与任务若干问题的商讨[J]. 地理学报, 1980,35(2):108-115. |
[ Shen Yuchang, Zuo Dakang , Tan Jian'an et al. The orientation and task of geography in China: A discussion of some problems. Acta Geographica Sinica, 1980,35(2):108-115.] | |
[36] | 唐晓峰 . 从混沌到秩序:中国上古地理思想史述论[M]. 北京: 中华书局, 2010. |
[ Tang Xiaofeng . From chaos to order: The review of ancient geographical thought in China. Beijing: Zhonghua Book Company, 2010.] | |
[37] | 张京祥 . 西方城市规划思想史纲[M]. 南京: 东南大学出版社, 2005. |
[ Zhang Jingxiang. History of urban planning in western cities. Nanjing: Southeast University Press, 2005.] | |
[38] | 陈彦光 . 地理学的贫困与出路(Ⅰ)——地理学危机的哲学思考[J]. 信阳师范学院学报(自然科学版), 1998,11(1):77-80. |
[ Chen Yanguang . Poverty and way-out of geography(Ⅰ): philosophy reflections on the geographical crisis. Journal of Xinyang Teachers College(Natural Science Edition), 1998,11(1):77-80.] | |
[39] | 刘笑敢 . 反向格义与中国哲学方法论反思[J]. 哲学研究, 2006(4):34-39. |
[ Liu Xiaogan . Reflection on Fanxiang Geyi (Reverse Analogical Interpretation) and the Methodology of Chinese Philosophy. Philosophical Researches, 2006(4):34-39.] | |
[40] | 周一星 . 城市研究的第一科学问题是基本概念的正确性[J]. 城市规划学刊, 2006(1):1-5. |
[ Zhou Yixing . The primary scientific issue of urban research in China is the correctness of basic urban concepts. Urban Planning Forum, 2006(1):1-5.] | |
[60] | de Blij H . Why geography matters: Three challenges facing America[M]. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007. |
[41] | 王丰龙, 曾刚 . 长江经济带研究综述与展望[J]. 世界地理研究, 2017,26(2):62-71. |
[1] | 刘建国,张妍,黄杏灵. 中国人文地理学区域空间结构研究的主要领域及展望[J]. 地理科学, 2019, 39(6): 874-885. |
[2] | 朱竑, 尹铎. 自然的社会建构:西方人文地理学对自然的再认识[J]. 地理科学, 2017, 37(11): 1609-1616. |
[3] | 金晓斌, 曹雪, 周寅康, 黄贤金, 高怡. 30年来中国地理学综合学术期刊中人文地理学论文载文分析[J]. 地理科学, 2012, 32(10): 1186-1192. |
[4] | 王丹. SCI、SSCI收录人文地理学期刊介绍及投稿建议[J]. 地理科学, 2010, 30(4): 636-642. |
[5] | 梁进社. 地理学的十四大原理[J]. 地理科学, 2009, 29(3): 307-315. |
[6] | 汤茂林. 中国人文地理学概论教材评价与建设献议[J]. 地理科学, 2007, 27(6): 859-864. |
[7] | 石崧, 宁越敏. 人文地理学“空间”内涵的演进[J]. 地理科学, 2005, 25(3): 340-345. |
[8] | 顾朝林, 刘海泳. 西方“马克思主义”地理学——人文地理学的一个重要流派[J]. 地理科学, 1999, 19(3): 237-242. |
|