随着城市化和再城市化的快速发展,上海城市地貌环境呈现出明显的致灾性。通过从地貌物质、地貌过程和地貌形态三方面进行了剖析,认为地貌物质中含水沙层广泛发育和层数多是地貌灾害发生的重要因素,其横向上的不连续性、成因和形成时间的差异性更为地貌灾害的发生埋下阴影;地势低平及中心城区碟形洼地的存在使得洪水构成对上海城市安全的最大威胁;高强度人类活动不仅改变城市自然地貌面(下垫面)的性质、特征和规模,而且直接导致它的沉降变形,从而使城市地貌环境更为脆弱和致灾机制的复杂化。特别是地貌形变过程的不可逆性,已引起城市自然地理其它要素(如水文、气候等)的一系列变化和造成城市生态环境的恶化,对城市规划建设起到明显的制约作用。上海只有重视城市地貌资源的合理利用和城市地貌环境的有效保护才能走上健康、持续的发展道路。
With the rapid development of urbanization and re-urbanization, the urban geomorphic environment (UGE) of Shanghai has ever been featured with obvious catastrophabilities. The latest disastrous and representative case is the water-seeping incident happened on July 1st 2003 in constructing the No.4 metro line (underground), which has caused a huge economic loss of 150×106 Yuan (RMB). In deed, this incident includes three continuous catastrophic stages—water seeping, land collapse and local flooding. It implies that the Shanghai's UGE has become sensitive, fragile, and therefore catastrophic under conditions of high pressure of human activities. Viewing from the geomorphic materials, geomorphic forms and geomorphic processes respectively, this paper discusses the catastrophabilities of UGE in Shanghai proper in relation to man-land interaction. From the geomorphic materials, the most catastrophic factor is the wide spread water-bearing sand-to-silt layers formed in different ages in Quaternary, which may cause water-seeping incidents under conditions of frequent engineering activities. They are well developed in this area and exist in different depths within the extent of the activities. From the geomorphic forms, Shanghai is an extremely flat land with low elevation as just emerged from the sea (the Yangtze delta). Since 1921 the central city has experienced strong land subsidence and formed a huge depression covering an area of 850 km2. Flood, therefore, has become the biggest threatening to the city both at present and in the future. And from the geomorphic processes, the high pressure of human activities has caused not only the tremendous changes of character, feature and dimensions of the physical landform, but also the deformation of the land surface due to land subsidence. The former, as we known, has given rise to changes in many aspects of urban climate and hydrology. The latter has led to a more serious sedimentary accumulation in the water channels (e.g. the Suzhou Creek and the Huangpu River etc.). The fragile and catastrophic UGE (especially the irreversible land deformation) will exert influences on the future urbanization and re-urbanization of Shanghai. Facts tell us that the Shanghai's UGE must be protected effectively and used rationally to keep us on the way of healthy, sustainable urban development.
[1] 刁承泰.城市地貌学[M].重庆:西南师范大学出版社,1999.158.
[2] 徐刚.山地城市地貌环境问题研究[J].中国环境科学,1997,(3):229~232.
[3] 丁锡祉,城市生态地貌的研究[J].地理科学,1992,12(1):1~7.
[4] 柏蓓,张凌,王进.上海轨道4号线事故调查三大技术原因酿成灾难[N].东方早报,2003-09-21.
[5] 许世远,黄仰松,范安康.上海地区地貌类型与地貌区划[A].见:严钦尚,许世远.长江三角洲现代沉积研究[C].上海:华东师范大学出版社,1987.320~328.
[6] 龚士良.上海城市建设对地面沉降的影响[J].中国地质灾害与防治学报,1998,9(2):108~111.
[7] 严学新,龚士良,曾正强,等.上海城区建筑密度与地面沉降关系分析[J].水文地质工程地质,2002,(6):21~25.
[8] 张修桂.上海浦东地区成陆过程辨析[J].地理学报,1998,(3):228~236.
[9] 李从先,范代读,张家强,等.长江三角洲地区晚第四纪地层及潜在环境问题[J].海洋地质与第四纪地质,2000,20(3):1~7.
[10] 王勇,左华.上海市地面沉降的经济损失评估[J].自然灾害学报,1993,2(1):16~22.
[11] 刘淑珍,钟祥浩.人类活动与地貌演化[A].见:杨景春.中国地貌特征与演化[C].北京:海洋出版社,1993.261~266.
[12] Stanely D J, Chen Z Y. Neolithic settlement distributions as a function of sea level-controlled topography in the Yangtze delta,China[ J]. Geology, 1997,24(12): 1083-1086.
[13] 严礼川.我国城市地面沉降概况[J].上海地质,1992,(1):40~48.
[14] 王兰生,等.城市发展中的地质环境演化与控制[J].地质灾害与环境保护,1997,(1):90~107.
[15] 张阿根,魏子新.上海地面沉降研究的过去、现在和未来[J].水文地质工程地质,2002,(5):72~75.
[16] 刘毅,张先林,万贵富,等.上海市近期地面沉降形势与对策建议[J].中国地质灾害与防治学报,1998,9(2):13~17.
[17] 魏子新,曾正强.上海市洪涝灾害的地面沉降因素及其长期影响[J].上海地质,2001,(2):12~15.
[18] 刘毅.地面沉降加重了1998年中国大洪灾[J].中国地质,1999,(1):30~32.
[19] 刘树人,周巧兰.上海市暴雨积水灾害成因及防治对策研究[J].现代城市研究,2000,(2):18.
[20] 许世远,陈振楼.苏州河底泥污染与整治[M].上海:上海科学技术出版社,2003.33.
[21] 沈恭.上海勘察设计志[M].上海:上海社会科学院出版社,1998.618~619.
[22] 汪松年.上海地区防汛形势和对策[J].城市道桥与防洪,2002,(2):24~27.
[23] 上海市民用建筑设计院(1985).上海市工程地质图集(内部资料).
[24] 上海市工程设计规范.地基基础设计规范(DGJ08-11-1999).